I love reading Savage Love in the City Pages here in Minneapolis. Last
night, during my workout, I read one letter that resonated w/ me.
Here’s the letter and Dan Savage’s response …
I think my
5-year-old nephew is probably gay. Most of the reasons are superficial
(he says that Zac Efron is cute), but I also have a hunch. If he is
gay, it’s cool by me. The problem is my brother also thinks his son
might be gay and he is NOT cool with it. He’s "nice" about it, but he
has taken to prohibiting most of the things my nephew loves to do:
putting on makeup, watching and dancing along to musicals with vampy
women (like Chicago), playing dress-up. My nephew can tell that his dad
thinks there is something shameful about his doing these things, but
asks me in the most heartbreaking way if we can do those things when
we’re at my house and not tell his dad.
Question 1: Is it even possible to tell the sexual preference of a child so young?
Question
2: Is it wrong for me to indulge my nephew even though my brother (his
parent) has told me that he doesn’t want my nephew doing those things?
Auntie Mame
Answer
1: There’s a 99 percent chance your nephew is gay and a 100 percent
chance that your brother will one day regret his actions. He’s
emotionally abusing his son—and for what? Dress-up or no dress-up, if
his son is gay then he’s going to be gay. Your brother can’t destroy
his son’s homosexuality, only his son’s life.
Answer
2: Your nephew needs an adult in his life who loves him unconditionally
and a space where he can express himself without fear. So tell him you
love him, promise to keep his secrets, and tell him that his father
loves him too and will come around one day. And yes, AM, lie to your
brother. In the grand scheme of things your lies are a misdemeanor; the
emotional violence he’s inflicting on his son is a felony.
Answer
3: You didn’t ask about an extra bedroom, but I wish you had.
Someday—someday soon—your nephew is going to need a safe place to go
when he starts running away from home. So put together a nice guest
bedroom, someplace your nephew can hide when he’s sick of his father
and, with any luck, over Zac Efron.
So, I wrote him this …
I
just read your letter from Auntie Mame and I have to tell you I had my
own Auntie Mame growing up in South Dakota which happens to be my
maternal Grandmother. I loved playing dress up and playing w/ dolls and
my stuffed animals and dancing, but I still liked playing w/ my GI Joes
and my trucks.
My Dad did not like that at all, so my Mom took
away my dolls and I stopped dancing and playing dress up. I was told
that it was wrong and I should play sports and not play dolls. I was
crushed, Dan. However, whenever I stayed over at my Grandma’s
apartment, I could dance, goof off and play w/ dolls.
It
didn’t help my hometown was about 700 people and I would constantly be
teased everyday until I graduated from high school. I moved on from
there and never looked back. When I was finally comfortable in my skin
being a fag, the first person I told was my Grandma. She told me she
loved me even if I was straight and she had a feeling I’m gay, but she
wanted me to figure it out.
My immediate family still struggles w/ me being gay, but it’s my life and I am living it the way I am.
Thank you for the wonderful advice you gave Auntie Mame
Sincerely,
Allen (and if you want, you can use my real name. I don’t care.)
PS … here is a pic of what I look like at 18 and now at 30.

A few minutes later, I got this …
wow — thanks for the great letter, and nice tits!
if your grandmother is still alive, tell i said she’s fucking
awesome. or just "awesome," if she disapproves of cussing.
xo
dan
I replied with this …
Oh,
she’s very much alive, still doing the NYTimes crossword puzzle in pen
every day, keeping active w/ the South Dakota Democrats … sometimes
she wears me out!
This is Grandma Elnore w/ my sister, Janelle.

Trust me, even though she does not swear EVER, she’d loved what you said.
Take care!
Here’s Dan’s response …
you’re so lucky to have her in your life!
Pretty neat, huh? And yes, I am VERY lucky to have my Grandma in my life.